Assassin's Creed

An Objective Independent Study’s Answer to Which AC is Best: March Madness Style!

I was told ___ vs. ___ battles weren’t welcome here, so I ran a study of my own with a select group of fans that jumped into AC at various points for minimal bias. I had one simple question I intended to answer as objectively and democratically as my humble cell of Assassins could muster: Which AC Title is the best?

The best way I thought to do that – what with the timing of March Madness – was a double-elimination bracket battle, so that’s just what we did!

24 combatants went head-to-head in 46 match-ups across 13 days, and with 405 total votes cast, I can now definitively crown (click if you wanna see the winner) Assassin’s Creed: Brotherhood the undefeated champion of the franchise!!! (At least in my findings)

Read more:  Assassin's Creed: The Franchise and Moving Forward

In all honesty, Brotherhood is my #1 pick anyways! 😉, so it wasn’t really surprising to see that title soar so far, but there were a few I thought would go much further that didn’t, and one in particular I did not see going far at all that made it through 4 rounds!

But I’m interested in hearing some further analysis from this community on our results! Did I set up fair-enough matches? Do you agree with our outcomes? What’s your #1 pick? Let’s discuss!!

  • Your Friendly Neighborhood Mentor

AC Bracket Battle Scores

Day 1, Winners Qualifiers

  • Altaïr’s Chronicles vs. Pirates 7 : 0
  • Bloodlines vs. III: Liberation 2 : 6
  • II: Discovery vs. Rebellion 3 : 3 (II:D wins toss)
  • Project Legacy vs. Memories 4 : 2
  • Recollection vs. Assassin’s Creed (Film) 2 : 5
  • Identity vs. Chronicles (C/I/R) 0 : 7
  • IV: Black Flag vs. Unity 10 : 1
  • Rogue vs. Syndicate 3 : 5

Day 2, Winners Round 1

  • Altaïr’s Chronicles vs. II: Discovery 3 : 2
  • Assassin’s Creed vs. Origins 7 : 5
  • Assassin’s Creed (Film) vs. Project Legacy 3 : 7
  • ACII vs. IV: Black Flag 7 : 4
  • Brotherhood vs. Revelations 6 : 5
  • ACIII vs. Odyssey 10 : 1
  • III: Liberation vs. Chronicles (C/I/R) 2 : 5
  • Valhalla vs. Syndicate 8 : 4

Day 3, Losers Round 1

  • Assassin’s Creed (Film) vs. Pirates 7 : 1
  • Bloodlines vs. II: Discovery 5 : 1
  • Identity vs. Rebellion 3 : 2
  • Memories vs. Recollection 5 : 0
  • Revelations vs. IV: Black Flag 8 : 5
  • Rogue vs. III: Liberation 8 : 1
  • Unity vs. Syndicate 7 : 4
  • Origins vs. Odyssey 12 : 1
Read more:  Sussex Arc thoughts *contains spoilers*

Day 4, Losers Round 2

  • Assassin’s Creed (Film) vs. Bloodlines 6 : 4
  • Identity vs. Memories 6 : 3
  • Revelations vs. Rogue 12 : 2
  • Unity vs. Origins 4 : 9

Day 5, Winners Round 2

  • Assassin’s Creed vs. Valhalla 7 : 6
  • Altaïr’s Chronicles vs. Chronicles (C/I/R) 3 : 6
  • ACII vs. ACIII 11 : 3
  • Brotherhood vs. Project Legacy 12 : 0

Day 6, Losers Round 3

  • Altaïr’s Chronicles vs. Assassin’s Creed (Film) 4 : 2
  • Project Legacy vs. Identity 4 : 2
  • ACIII vs. Revelations 3 : 8
  • Valhalla vs. Origins 4 : 8

Day 7, Winners Semifinals

  • Assassin’s Creed vs. Brotherhood 5 : 4
  • ACII vs. Chronicles (C/I/R) 5 : 0

Day 8, Losers Round 4

  • Altaïr’s Chronicles vs. Project Legacy 3 : 4
  • Revelations vs. Origins 6 : 7

Day 9, Losers Round 5

  • Assassin’s Creed vs. Project Legacy 13 : 0
  • Chronicles (C/I/R) vs. Origins 1 : 10

Day 10, Winners Championships!

  • ACII vs. Brotherhood 5 : 7

Day 11, Losers Semifinals

  • Origins vs. ACII 4 : 9

Day 12, Losers Championships!

  • Assassin’s Creed vs. ACII 4 : 9

Day 13, THE FINAL ROUND!!!

  • Brotherhood vs. ACII 5 : 3

Undefeated All-Time Champion!!!

35 Brotherhood 5W

Eliminated Scores

55 Origins 5W

49 ACII 5W

39 Revelations 3W

35 Assassin’s Creed 3W

23 Assassin’s Creed (Film) 3W

20 Altaïr’s Chronicles 3W

19 Project Legacy 4W

19 Chronicles (C/I/R) 3W

19 Black Flag 1W

18 Valhalla 1W

16 ACIII 1W

13 Rogue 1W

13 Syndicate 1W

12 Unity 1W

11 Identity 2W

11 Bloodlines 1W

9 III: Liberation 1W

8 Memories 1W

6 II: Discovery 1T

5 Rebellion 1T

2 Odyssey

2 Recollection

1 Pirates

Percentage of Total Votes

13.58% Origins

12.09% ACII

9.63% Revelations

8.64% Brotherhood

8.64% Assassin’s Creed

5.68% Assassin’s Creed (Film)

4.94% Altaïr’s Chronicles

4.69% Project Legacy

4.69% Chronicles (C/I/R)

4.69% Black Flag

4.44% Valhalla

3.95% ACIII

3.21% Rogue

3.21% Syndicate

2.96% Unity

2.72% Identity

2.72% Bloodlines

2.22% III: Liberation

1.78% Memories

1.48% II: Discovery

1.23% Rebellion

0.49% Odyssey

0.49% Recollection

0.25% Pirates

Source

Read more:  Assassin's Creed Syndicate is way BETTER than I thought it was

Similar Guides


More about Assassin's Creed

Post: "An Objective Independent Study’s Answer to Which AC is Best: March Madness Style!" specifically for the game Assassin's Creed. Other useful information about this game:





Top 20 NEW Medieval Games of 2021

Swords, dragons, knights, castles - if you love any of this stuff, you might like these games throughout 2021.



10 NEW Shooter Games of 2021 With Over The Top Action

We've been keeping our eye on these crazy action oriented first and third person shooter games releasing this year. What's on your personal list? Let us know!



Top 10 NEW Survival Games of 2021

Survival video games are still going strong in 2021. Here's everything to look forward to on PC, PS5, Xbox Series X, Nintendo Switch, and beyond.



You Might Also Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *