I haven't played much DH, so I decided to do some testing, as I plan to start next season with DH.
I removed everything that affects my damage, and crafted a low level bow and crossbow that were as close to the same dps as possible, and went to spam a Zombie that doesn't self heal (so I could check the health differences) and couldn't damage me through my regen.
If you plan on leveling with Massacre bonus, melee weapon is not a good option, because Hungering Arrow feels SUPER good at keeping the stacks.
Crossbow is quite a lot better at leveling than a bow. I was surprised how big the difference is, because bows almost always shows "more damage", mainly because of the speed.
Impale vs. Fan:
Massacre: Fan of Knives is better at leveling than Impale, unless you are lucky and get HPS (Holy Point Shot) Quiver at lvl 31, which you should save your shards on, especially if you happen to start the season with Karlei's.
Rifts: Impale is at least more fun than Fan of Knives, if not also better, depending on maps
Basically Fan of Knives deals 400% damage per second in the background even if you're dodging around, pulling a mob behind you with hungering arrow or just grouping up enemies. Also when you decide to use all that damage, it does a big AoE.
Impale does 375% damage, and only when you have time to attack, which is usually not more than one attack per second, if that. Also the damage isn't as big AoE, it just impales.
Impale does more damage to less targets, and the amount of targets is why I prefer Fan of Knives.
Here are some numbers I got (all numbers are without HPS Quiver):
Damage: 43 003
Damage: 38 401
Difference: 4602 (crossbow)
Difference/s: 395 (bow)
20 unbuffed impales
Damage: 142 903
Damage: 107 184
Diff: 35 719 (crossbow)
20 unbuffed fans
Damage: 100 929
Damage: 75 687
Diff: 25 242 (crossbow)
10 buffed impale
Damage: 263 780
Damage: 201 030
Diff: 62 750 (crossbow)
1 buffed 10sec fan
Damage: 167 400
Damage: 119 170
Diff: 48 230 (crossbow)
Damage: 978 240
dmg/sec: 32 608
Damage: 1 028 849
dmg/sec: 34 295
Diff: 50 609 (bow)
Diff/s: 1687 (bow)
4x 10sec Fan (30 sec)
Damage: 650 837
dmg/sec: 21 696
Damage: 541 523
dmg/sec: 18 051
Diff: 109 314 (crossbow)
Diff/s: 3644 (crossbow)
- need help with uul nethol’s embrace bone nova – the impaler
- Dual Wielding Hand Crossbows: Definitive discussion thread
- Armorer Artificer’s Power Armor weapons counting as one-handed weapons
More about DiabloPost: "DH leveling, difference between Bow and Crossbow / Impale and Fan of Knives" specifically for the game Diablo. Other useful information about this game:
- The ‘why play classic’ Question
- How I completed Challenge Rift 215 on console (NA)
- Ethereal Farming for Quest Reward (2 Accounts or 2 Players required)
- BurritoGuy the Guardian!
- [D2:R] Some of you guys are going to be ultra hardcore scammed in trades. Diablo 2 changed a lot after patch 1.13 (2010). Some quick explanation and a story that broke my heart today
Top 20 NEW Medieval Games of 2021
Swords, dragons, knights, castles - if you love any of this stuff, you might like these games throughout 2021.
10 NEW Shooter Games of 2021 With Over The Top Action
We've been keeping our eye on these crazy action oriented first and third person shooter games releasing this year. What's on your personal list? Let us know!
Top 10 NEW Survival Games of 2021
Survival video games are still going strong in 2021. Here's everything to look forward to on PC, PS5, Xbox Series X, Nintendo Switch, and beyond.