I'm a console player rated in low-mid gold on both support and tank. I say this to emphasize that I am not an pro at Overwatch — however, I do have a graduate degree in applied statistics and came here to say that I think Overwatch has a statistics problem.
Most of us who use LFG to find teammates have found ourselves in an awkward position:
- Join group
- Group leader checks stats
- Group leader becomes statistician
- Group leader then gives you backhanded compliments and explains why you can't play with their precious group.
- Small back-and-fourth debate, mild toxicity
- You get kicked from group or or leave out of frustration.
The biggest problem I see in this scenario, and it goes both ways, is that stats/10 is not a good metric to base arguments of how good or bad a player is. Here is my reasoning, and please someone correct me and help me understand where I'm wrong:
Every game is different. I won't explain in detail, but we should be able to agree that your heals/10 as a Mercy might look different across games where you were asked to pocket vs. main heal (generally less heals given in a pocket-heavy game). This game-to-game difference is called variance and it's almost entirely neglected in our Overwatch calculus. Instead, we focus on the averages of in-game stats.
Just because I get 10k heals/10 doesn't mean I'll deliver anything close to that in the next game. I might be at 6k but contribute 2k damage boosting and give a ton of Rez's on cooldown.
OW is a complicated game, and to try and boil down in-game performance to just 1 metric seems unfair. It would be like if the NFL only used the 40-yard dash as a metric of a player's ability on the field. It says nothing about their strength, technique or game IQ. Similarly, we are missing a lot of other information by focusing solely on stats/10.
I won't give a whole stats lesson here, but I just wanted to bring to light a common issue I see in LFG cues. To reiterate, stats/10 isn't the worst metric, but it doesn't tell the full story and might actually be doing more harm than good, especially when coupled with the misunderstanding of what averages actually tell us vs. what they don't tell us.
I suggest 2 things to help alleviate this: 1) The OW community needs to layoff using stats/10 as a tell-all metric. It's OK at best and just statistically ignorant at worst. 2) Blizzard should supplement the stats/10 metric with variance from your average. This will give other players a better idea of your game-to-game consistency while also helping the OW community become more sophisticated in statistics like many other major sports.
TL;DR: stats/10 doesn't take into consider variance and without variance then your interpretation of in-game performance suffers. Blizzard should help us out by installing a variance metric to help propel the sport into the world of analytics. Meanwhile, OW players need to be nicer and not kick people for not having their made-up gold standard of what "good" is — because truthfully, your gold standard is a flawed one.
- Message from Overwatch streamer with cerebral palsy
- BlizzcOnline Day 2 Megathread
- Ironically, winning doesn’t increase your SR – performing better does.
More about OverwatchPost: "Why stats/10 is" specifically for the game Overwatch. Other useful information about this game:
- How does everybody stack up heading into the June Joust? (NA)
- A Guide to “brig diff”-ing your Competitive Matches! (including replay code!)
- Using IBM Watson to create OWL Play of the Game(s)
- How to turn bad games into good games with shot calling!
- The problem with immortality field is more complicated than you might think…
Top 20 NEW Medieval Games of 2021
Swords, dragons, knights, castles - if you love any of this stuff, you might like these games throughout 2021.
10 NEW Shooter Games of 2021 With Over The Top Action
We've been keeping our eye on these crazy action oriented first and third person shooter games releasing this year. What's on your personal list? Let us know!
Top 10 NEW Survival Games of 2021
Survival video games are still going strong in 2021. Here's everything to look forward to on PC, PS5, Xbox Series X, Nintendo Switch, and beyond.